Poll - Do You think Violence is a Public Health Issue?

As C. Everett Koop has written in the Foreward to Violence in America: A Public Health Approach (Rosenberg and Fenley, 1991), “Over the years we have tacitly and, I believe, mistakenly agreed that violence was the exclusive province of the police, the courts, and the penal system.” Koop writes that when we ask our criminal justuice system to concentrate more on the prevention of violence and to provide additional services for victims, we may begin to overburden this system. “At that point, Koop writes, “the professions of medicine, nursing and the health-related social services must come forward and recognize violence as their issue and one that profoundly affects the public health.”

What do you think? Should violence be considered a public health issue?



14 Comments:

Posted by Brian Timber on April 15th, 2013 at 03:08 AM

Of course violence is a serious public health concern. I heard Greg Ganske speaking on this subject on the public radio the other night. He had some creative ideas about how to handle violence and how to encourage our youth to express their anger in non-violent forms.

Posted by major lazer on April 9th, 2013 at 05:57 AM

As John Studzinski once told me, anything can become a public health issue if you let this happen. Violence is in every and each one of us and i do not think that we should make it more personal than it is.

Posted by Setgvb on March 22nd, 2013 at 06:07 AM

I think that a health issue regarding public violence is the last step that you should take in consideration. Nobody should suffer after a fight in public. I did some nighthawk radiology research and then crossed my mind that the law isn’t as it should be.

Posted by banik on February 16th, 2013 at 06:23 AM

In the field of healthcare initiating certain changes is necessary. It is reassuring for us to see that initiatives for reform have been taken, hopefully, more positive steps would follow which would contribute to the overall growth of the sector.

Posted by Annie Dora on December 29th, 2012 at 03:54 AM

After hearing news of school shootings or other violence, it’s natural for students — no matter how old they are or where they go to school — to worry about whether this type of incident may someday happen to them. Contracting this fear is the worst thing that can happen to them, that’s why these days, violence is a public health issue of maximum importance.

Posted by Danielle on December 13th, 2012 at 01:03 PM

I asked this in an interview. Whose problem is school violence? The answer is all of ours. Just as it is a problem we all must deal with, it is also a problem we all must work to solve. The community, the administrators, the teachers, the parents, and the students must come together and make schools safe. Otherwise, prevention and punishment will not be effective.

Posted by annie s on October 19th, 2012 at 01:05 PM

Violence has been a widespread problem since the beginning of civilization. It’s hard to stop violence amongst individuals when our own nation engages in war and combat to settle their problems, but we have to take it upon ourselves to set an example and put an end to the nonsensical abuse. Stopping violence starts by changing your own ways, and spreading the word to others, getting jobs in healthcare is one way to help.

Posted by Tori on October 17th, 2012 at 03:41 AM

According to Evolv Health, rampant school violence is a problem for parents and educators alike. These problems can strike anywhere, anytime. When parents and teachers know how to stop school violence, they can help to make a safer environment for the students. All in all, violence is a true public health issue and we must stop it from spreading.

Posted by Visitor on April 2nd, 2009 at 07:29 AM

Health care providers can play an important role in identifying and responding to victims of domestic violence through routine screening and appropriate referral.
http://www.neu-pro.com

10  Posted by Visitor on February 16th, 2009 at 02:17 AM

Domestic violence is a serious, underlying cause of poor health for many people in the Commonwealth. Health care providers can play an important role in identifying and responding to victims of domestic violence through routine screening and appropriate referral.
marirea penisului

11  Posted by Lea Sevey on December 26th, 2008 at 11:31 AM

Ask anyone if they have experienced a violent incident or know someone who has and they will say yes. Violence has touched every single person in some form or another. It has a ripple effect that touches us in our homes, workplaces, and on the streets. Interpersonal violence not only has an impact upon the individuals at the time, but such trauma lingers through short term (and long term) mental health and physical problems as well as economic troubles. Domestic violence shelters throughout the country are filling to capacity and have more requests for assistance than ever before. Help our communities help themselves by taking a stand to speak out against violence; voice your opinions to policy makers, report child abuse, volunteer at a shelter, and simply don’t tolerate voilence laden comments by people you come into contact with.

Lea Sevey
Executive Director
Oasis Shelter Home, Inc.

12  Posted by liv on December 19th, 2008 at 07:03 PM

absolutely!!!  as someone that has dedicated their career to working with survivors or domestic and sexual violence, i don’t understand how the question could even be posed.  we see on a daily basis how violence impacts survivors health - physically, mentally and emotionally.  perhaps if society could shift the way it looked at dv/sa to a public health issue, we might see better developed resources for both survivors and offenders.  we might be able to better develop programs that work with people to break the cycle and in the end improve overall health issues.

13  Posted by Cindy Solari on December 1st, 2008 at 03:02 PM

Violence is a public health issue in such a substantial way, I am surprised the question even needs to be asked. The cause of violence is a direct reflection of our community, the school system, education, home life, mental health issues, and social understanding. It’s origin, be it environmental or organic, is (at best) widely disputed. Yet, it is a crucial understanding needed to assist in the prevention, treatment, punishment, and recovery of it’s existence and effect. The trauma it causes the victims, their family and friends, the person responsible for the violence and their family and friends, as well as the professionals and community that address it’s existence and the after math, in and of itself is a health epidemic. The fear it generates, the cycle it creates, and the attention it needs in response and prevention take a large toll on many of our governmental, community, and private organizations, both in funds and in resources. Addressing violence is far more a health issue than it is an issue of criminal justice. And until we recognize the entire scope of its reach, it will continue to plague our society and drain our resources. From our justice department and medical organizations, to our government assistance programs and schools; it is quite possibly the most dangerous and expensive health issue our society faces today.

14  Posted by D. Dow on October 27th, 2008 at 06:59 PM

Yes, violence is a serious public health issue. At this point we know that exposure to violence may, and oftentimes does, result in PTSD. Which is no longer a theory but a treatable/treated condition. Parents are oftentimes concerned about the violent videogames their children play. But some of the most popular games, Grand Theft Auto for example, are based on an inner-city reality for many children and adults alike. So if one set of parents are rightly concerned that their children will be adversely affected by fictional violence then we should all be very concerned by the very real violence that some of us experience on an almost daily basis. We also now know how destructive stress is on the body and brain. (If violence doesn’t cause stress I cannot imagine what does.) So if a lot of our fellow citizens live in a violent, stressful world then their health will be impacted - which impacts us all.




Join the conversation. Leave a comment.

Name: (required)

Email: (required) will not be published

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Submit the word you see below:


Back to main